Please install Flash Player to view this content.
  User ID :
 
  Password :
 
 
Forgot password
  Skip Navigation Links
 








Judgement


Judgment on Complaint against Apple Daily (Chinese Only)


本會於今年3月3日收到許先生電郵,投訴當天於蘋果日報網站刊登的一則新聞「女遊客曼谷機場半裸 網民:是中國遊客吧」。他的投訴如下:

 
1. 指控報道的記者缺乏德觀念,指被偷拍者是受害者,「敢問廁所換衫有何不妥?」
 
2. 偷拍者應是犯人,被偷拍者應是受害者,但《蘋果日報》卻指摘被偷拍者。
 
3. 《蘋果日報》具有反中傾向。
 
本會經查明後,認為投訴並不成立。理由如下:
 
(A) 有關報道是綜合台灣中央社及泰國《曼谷郵報》報道,是引述外電報道。本委員會認為《蘋果日報》綜合兩項外電消息報道,照片則轉載自網上社交媒體,報道中亦明確指出「女遊客國籍尚未確認」,又指認為事主是中國人的指控,是來自網民判斷。
 
(B) 委員會認為,此宗報道屬網上熱話式的轉載新聞,新聞本身有色情或淫褻的成份,刊登時可能令外界質疑其品味。該旅客的行為在泰國當地惹來爭議,亦有泰國傳媒報道事件,《蘋果日報》是引述泰國當地爭議。
 
(C) 《蘋果日報》是否反中,屬讀者主觀判斷,本會無法證實。
 
 
 
 
香港記者協會操守委員會
2015年7月23日
 
23/07/2015 13:38:00   updated more
Previous: Judgment on Complaint against Wen Wei Po (Chinese Only)
Next: Judgment on Complaint against HKET (Chinese Only)

 

  

Powered by   
 
 


Judgement (19-08-2015)

 

HKJA's Facebook Page

   
  HKJA_49th_pdf
  HKJA_47th_pdf
   
  2013 Annual Rpeort
 

2017 Annual_report: Two Systems Under Siege

2016 Annual Report: One Country Two Nightmares 

[ Press Release ] [ All years ]

   
  2009 Human Rights Press Awards
  The20th Human Rights Press Awards [Details]
   
  China News reporters Harassment Form
  Online Questionaire for China news reporters on harassment at work"
..... [
Online] / [Paper Form]
   
  17th Consumer Right Press Awards
  "17th Consumer Right Press Awards "  
   

 

HKJA's Publication: "The Journalist"
 

A publication provides updated news about HKJA and media industry.. [ Details ]

FEBRUARY 2016 ISSUE

   
  Subscription to "People will not forget"
  "People will not forget" - A HKJA's Publication for the June 4 Incident
Online Version .. [ Detail ]
Subscription .. [ Detail ]
   
  Kevin Lau Incident Concern Group
   
   

 

 
Other Publications
  Reporter Manual in China
 
More